Showing posts with label Thoughts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Thoughts. Show all posts

Thursday, February 12, 2009

Commitment

Room dividers tend to look cheap. I always thought it was because by
nature, a room divider looks like an after thought, or a flimsy fix
for bad architecture. I think that's partially true, but I think the
main reason is that room dividers can easily lack commitment. Making a
wall involves commitment. A room divider can be changed at any time,
so it exists in an inarticulate state. It's similar to the reason so
many Photoshop images look weak—created in layers, they look like the
artist has never made a commitment which results in an image with an
ambiguous, aimless, tepid quality. So room dividers or cheap fixes can
probably look OK if done with purpose and authority that comes from
commitment.

Don't get all Sharper Image on me

You have to be careful I think when using reproduction vintage items
like a phone booth. This gas tank from Road Relics, for example, is
kind of cool but looks too much like an "I'm an unmarried guy with too
much money and a rec room and I saw this at Sharper Image" kind of a
purchase. Road Relics has both conventional gas tanks as well as ones
that turn into displays as shown above. The nicest one has a hole for
a TV set.

Saturday, January 31, 2009

Trying to buy displays

1. I was at Lowe's looking at bead board. It was ugly, like painted fake pine paneling. As I turned the pages of the display I saw something that looked like masonite. Finally, I thought, a nice honest material. I then discovered that what I was looking at was an empty display case.

2. When I was at Hacienda on Colorado, I saw a great rustic cabinet with dozens of drawers used to sell hardware. The guy said it cost "seven" so I thought it was $700 which would not be unreasonable. Of course, it ended up that he was referring to the hardware that sells for $7 a piece and the drawer was not for sale.

3. I was at Ikea looking for something that might make a good range hood. I saw these white metal buckets and a price tag that said $7. That is a great price for the bucket, I thought. Having been burned before I decided this was too good to be true and indeed it was—the $7 was for the flowers inside the bucket and the bucket was part of the display.

4. This whole experience has become so commonplace that I just assume that if I like it, it's not for sale. I was at Habitat for Humanity and found some nice drawers. Yes, they were just the display.

Slats & I just realized where the blog name comes from




For several weeks now I have been obsessed with the idea of putting slats on the living room wall next to the fireplace, my take on the Eichler bead board. I found that there are quite a few wood slat products out there, from retail display systems that go horizontally, to acoustic ceiling baffles. Yesterday at Ikea, I found the perfect prototyping solution—the Mandal headboard. Amazingly, it is just under eight feet tall so it fits the wall perfectly when I rotate it sideways. I told Mark that I have three obsessions—lines, floating planes and slats (which are basically planes made of lines). The slats are unusual, but I like them. I suspect it's the way they express the intersection of Japanese and ranch house sensibilities. I guess I could actually use several of these headboard systems placed together on the wall (at the cost of about $750) but I'm not sure how I feel about the knotty pine.

As the project goes on I find that my raw materials are second-level raw materials. They're not wood and metal as much as products that I can reconfigure. So rather than trudging into the forest to cut down a pine tree or Home Depot to find a pine board, I trudge into Ikea to find a pine headboard. Note that you really have to go to the Ikea "forest" for this to work. In a catalog picture (top), you can't see the material clearly. Hiking into Ikea to find raw materials. That's what it means to live in the urban wild.

Thursday, January 15, 2009

Home Depot hardware


I keep making the same mistake and keep having the same revelation over and over. Somewhere I have this belief that novices are innocent and that their initial attempts to do things are crude, generic, and simplistic. In reality, however, beginners imitate what they've seen from the 'outside in.' So it should come as no surprise that Home Depot hardware is so ugly. I always ask myself, "why would they make all those weird designs? Wouldn't it be easier to just make something more generic and simple? Why make all this fancy-but-ugly stuff?" Alas, I am misunderstanding the problem. It's easier to make something fancy and ugly. Simplicity and unselfconsciousness are characteristics of good design, not the hallmarks of a novice. Plus, I think marketing is involved. A piece of hardware needs to sell itself. It needs to look like something. I'm always looking for hardware that looks like nothing.

Found objects again

I think that what gives found objects their presence is that we make ourselves subject to them. We must wait for them to appear. Not bound by our control, they become unselfconscious, or as Chris Alexander might say, "egoless."

Monday, January 12, 2009

Character

It is pleasant to surround ourselves with artifacts and spaces that connote use, history and wear—things that have 'character.' The question is how do we do this? It is one thing to buy an antique, one thing to have an heirloom passed down to us and still another thing to build a home with used, worn wood.

I was telling Mark that perhaps all this time I should have been saving construction materials to use in my house. A scrap of wood here, a set of tiles there. I could then incorporate these meaningful found objects into a new house or remodel. Mark's response was that people who do that sort of thing usually do the building themselves (like Ben's idea of making a studio out of crates and pallets). Plus, I realized later, this is impractical. Are you really going to buy 500 feet of hardwood flooring to save for future use?

Mark's solution was to fully participate in the process of buying materials. He stumbled upon the sturdy outdoor tiles that he would eventually (mis)use for his kitchen counter. The important thing, he said, was to look at the nature of the material, not its official name or designated use. Another example was when he bought the tiles for his floor. During his purchase he learned about "seconds," which are usually used for paving sidewalks. Unlike firsts (?) they have subtle grooves, like handsawn wood. Mark saw this not only as an opportunity to save money, but as a way to add character to his floor.

Ben's solution was different. Their family bought an old, crooked house in 'the hood.' As an older home it has some nice details that they were able to uncover. Britton's quarters, for example, has some beautiful wood floors—one floor beautiful by anyone's account and another floor that is stained, worn and extraordinarily rustic. It provides a lovely contrast to the drywall and newer fixtures.

So how to add this wear, age and character to my remodel? Built in 1950, there are no interesting details in the house except for the parquet floors which are coming apart at the edges and need to be replaced. What about taking a more hands-on approach with materials like Mark? Maybe. Architectural salvage firms? Likely expensive and not my style, but I admit I am intrigued by Tap -n- Tile's vintage and salvaged tile collection (they're local). So far I've come up with three solutions.

1. Certain design details infer age, place and character. For example, tile can be used in ways that not only adds beauty, but creates a sense of connection with the era in which the home was designed.

2. I've spun on a dime and begun to think about furnishing the house with vintage, antique or similar items. Less metal, more wood.

3. I'm now thinking of incorporating more of my own inventor-like sensibility into the home and interior design. For example, today I was looking at my old Ikea track light. It suddenly struck me that this is a low voltage item that I can modify it to my taste like one of my circuit-bent instruments. I may take out the metal tracks and string it with wire to create a low tech track system. I like the idea that Sean might grow up in a place that is fundamentally educational, a place that reveals possibilities for exploration and modification.

Found objects

Last year, one of the grad students who works with found objects was showing me one of her projects. Using an archaeological metaphor, she walked around a park hoping to find items that spoke to the park's past or history of use. What she picked up was a lot of wrappers and plastic bottles, mostly trash.

In her studio, however, is a beautifully worn cabinet covered in paint. It is a true found object, something she found in the street. Found objects are things that call out to us. By their nature we just happen upon them like the perfect stone or the perfect chest. Found objects cannot be found on a deadline. We must wait for them to appear.

Today I found two beautiful twigs that I had been keeping for years in the garage. I think I've had them since I lived in Indiana, more than ten years ago. I didn't have any purpose in mind when I stored them away. Today I got the idea that they'd make nice coat hangars, my own version of the ones I've been looking at on the web.

Found objects have a unique presence. You can't go outside and say, "I'm going to find a found object today." You have either stumble upon one or be willing to wait for it to appear as you step through your life.

Wabi sort of


Wabi sabi is a Japanese aesthetic of transience. Rather than valuing new things, wabi sabi reveres the old, the worn, the used. Wabi sabi accepts imperfections and patina. It underscores the temporal nature of existence. This idea is very attractive because of the rich way in which it articulates an aesthetic of simplicity.

But wabi sabi is not unproblematic. It is an excrutiatingly refined philosophy, one that asks us to make minute, connoiseur-like discriminations sometimes divorced from important daily concerns. Like many ontological belief systems, wabi sabi seems to exist outside of ethics. The Silver Pavillion (dry garden shown above) is sometimes thought of as an example of wabi sabi. Yet, created as a retreat during a time of war, it was built on the backs of many people. Even today, its expressed simplicity requires an extraordinary amount of maintenance. Its very essence lies in its transitory construction, something that cannot be solidified in concrete, but must be tended to carefully by hand.

Ikea


A few months ago, I let Sean hammer my old Clubbo coffee table. It's a beautifully proportioned table (above) that looks like something you'd get at Shelter for a couple of grand. But the finish wore off quickly so I let Sean have at it. I was surprised to see that the table was actually made of honeycombed cardboard, not MDF or fiberboard. The light weight should have been a clue.

Despite this, I've been appreciating Ikea more. I found you just have to look at the right things. There are quite a few solid wood items, usually made of pine, that are nice. The Hemnes bedside table (below) is $59 and made of solid wood. It's under-scaled like most Ikea furniture and the paint isn't too nice. But it would look great refinished.

I found that part of getting older means that you live in places longer and expect things to last longer and therefore appreciate the longevity of solid wood pieces.

Tuesday, January 6, 2009

Old mission statement

Not too long ago I found this on one of my hard disks—a mission statement written when Maria and I were interviewing architects five years ago.

What people might say about this house when it's done

In this airy, breezy house all eyes are directed toward the backyard which serves as a visual backdrop and outdoor "room" for informal living. With subtle touches of tropical, modernist, asian and primitive influences, this home values proportion over size and usability over ideology. The ideals of ranch house living are still retained in the integration of indoor and outdoor spaces and flowing design. The cook does not work behind the scenes but is an essential part of everyday life. Rooms are mostly sleeping areas and provide for privacy when needed. But most of the living, studying and working takes place in community areas, an Asian take on life reinterpreted for California living. Suprisingly, the attention to detail in this house doesn't come from expensive features or interior design. Most of the walls are simple plaster or dry wall. Fixtures are mass-produced stock. There's nothing tricky or expensive about the construction: standardized sizes are used throughout to trim costs. Exposed woods aren't exotic, but readily available selections. Instead, detail comes from an attention to proportion and fit. You won't find doorways crammed under low ceilings and unthoughtful, space-eating nooks and crannies. You won't find moldings used as a seam-fixing panacea or trendy adornments. What you will find is an integrated, thoughtful space that feels custom-tailored for its owners yet is flexible enough to adopt to a number of living styles.

Monday, January 5, 2009

Phase 2 project goals (revised)

Beyond being on time and on budget.

1. Create sufficient lead time for decisions
How do we anticipate decisions that need to be made so there is enough time for me to think them through and not make them at the last minute? Indicator that we don't have this right—me getting lots of phone calls at work.

2. Consider the design implications of even the smallest decisions. Example: what I thought was a fireplace "lip" was actually a fireplace "surround"—a big difference I didn't have the background to understand. Even the closet pole was partially a design decision that I mistook for a building decision. Granted, this is all due to my ignorance. Another way to look at this: you are not mere implementers of a design, but making micro-level design decisions to match an overall sensibility.

3. Develop/articulate ways to aid decision-making
What are the most effective, appropriate, quickest and inexpensive ways to test, visualize and understand the outcome of decision possibilities? Offer appropriate techniques and approaches to help clients come to a decision. One obvious technique: taping paper on the walls to see if I can live with only two smallish windows to the backyard. The answer: no.

4. Allow for flexibility in process. For example, I'd like to break the building process into steps to enable sufficient time for review (e.g., creation of plate, etc.) This is my solution to the gradual stiffening problem.

5. Anticipate usability and functionality problems. Will the doors open OK? (you did this with the new door). Will I need an outlet here? Do I need a rounded edge so I don't cut myself? Is this sharp thing at a child's eye level? Will I need lighting there? Will an animal scratch this floor? Usability should be considered from a variety of points of view: older people, adults, children, pets, long term visitors, short term visitors, etc. One of the people who bid on my backyard said, "I notice that you have some children's toys back here. If you have kids, I highly recommend St. Augustine since it's much tougher than Marathon." The other guy said, "Marathon? OK." Which do you think I'm more likely to call back when it's time? Not only that, the one guy upsold me and I was happy about it. This should almost be like a template. Client has a dog? Floors should be scratch resistant, maybe doggy door, stronger base cabinets, etc. Client has a child? Ameliorate dust concerns, health hazards, sharp edges, consider non-toxic materials, low VOC/gas adhesives, etc.? Client is old? Rails, universal access, non-slip tub, etc. For example, the fact that my mom might come to stay for awhile should set the template in motion: redoing bathroom? Old person? Might mean rails. Also, don't be fooled by the names of things. Think spaces instead of names. For example, a lot of people don't eat in their dining rooms and may use a nook for all kinds of things. Help to make sure the area is functional as a space, not only for its intended purpose. Does it have adequate light, ventilation and power? What about insulation?

6. Foster a concern for needs of occupants. For example, can you minimize time the water heater is offline? Make sure that gas pilot lights are on after working on gas line. Make sure there is reasonable security and protection from elements. Will electricity ever be out? Where is the saw placed? Is it important that we are able to access the basketball court, etc.?

7. Demonstrate understanding of nature of the project. For instance, working on a craftsman style home is different from working on a tract home. How are these differences reflected in construction? This includes understanding the value of things within context. For example, maybe that floor is really worth saving (as you did mention). Maybe those original cabinets should really be refinished instead of replaced because you can't buy them anymore. This kind of advice can be helpful and save money. Do you have expertise in matching old stuff with new stuff? The people I worked with at the auto body shop were experts at this. They would get the specs on the car color, eyeball the effects of sun and wear then mix up a seamless paint match. One way to figure out what people are envisioning in their projects is to see what they're reading or look at their remodeling scrapbooks (or in my case, website).

8. Exhibit pride of workmanship. Good craftsmen often like to show off the details of their work. It doesn't matter whether it was hard or not. What matters is why it's good. This makes everyone happy.

9. Do a good job of cleaning up when appropriate. This is hard. Even the super-expensive, super-technical lead abatement guys left skid marks in my driveway.

10. Provide flexibility in communication. If I want to communicate via email or web will you do it?

11. Be an interface to the building process. I found that many companies I deal with have two levels of personnel. One person is the client interface. The other personnel do the work. In a small firm you have to do both.

12. Believe that people skills triumph over contracts and technology. You can have clients sign off on all kinds of things, but in the end, if the client isn't happy you will be blamed. Solve problems before you or the client gets unhappy. But of course, contracts and agreements are important too.

13. Understand that rules, institutions and methodologies, at their best, are expressive, not restrictive. Guidelines, when thought of properly, are freeing. They provide ways to help you express a concern for others and a concern for craft. They can make it easier to see things from a variety of viewpoints. As your bid says, "I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me."

14. Above all: continue to be easy to work with, ethical & try to find equitable ways to resolve problems, working in good faith.



Saturday, January 3, 2009

Thoughts on remodeling

>Do a test project first.

>Mark--do big things first.

>Cheap remodeling error: room in a room--you add a room or covered area or patio to the outside of a house. The former outside room now becomes a room within a room. Dark, weird and useless.

>Cheap remodeling error: room at the end of a room. You put a new room next to an existing bedroom. Now, in order to get to the new room you have to go through the existing bedroom.

>Bad styling error. Without taking into account the character and background of your house, you try to convert it into something else through the use of cheap stylistic devices. The former owners tried to turn our ranch house into an Italian villa with vineyard wallpaper and metal vine toilet paper holders.

>Ben's rule of even tempered development. Know what your house is and develop toward that. In other words, know if your house is a simple house or a showcase and choose items/design accordingly.

>Mark-keep your options open.

>The storyboard metaphor. The plan enables you to work with what's there. It isn't the law.

>Expect to make mistakes. They're an inevitable part of the learning process.

>Contemporaneous multiple use vs. serial multiple use. In a creative house, you need places to leave work out. The idea that you can convert spaces frequently is not conducive to creativity. Serial multiple use is the way to go.

>Every horizontal surface attracts clutter

>Space needs to imply human activity

>The unfolding characteristics of a house come partially from its occlusions. Without occlusions, the eye and body is not led through a space.

>Ideas for testing: prototyping, paper prototypes, spatial prototypes, masking tape prototypes, string prototypes.

>Classic design strategy: visualize the space in progress via layers. First, as an owner, a potential buyer, different people, etc.

>A huge part of design is shaping information. I learned this from my pantry items. I like keeping pasta in glass because it gives you an intuitive sense of what you have and how much. When kept in tins, you have to remember or guess. Same goes for rooms. Is this a room that you want private or partially 'transparent?' A glass door is not simply a design option or a way of letting light into a space. It also implies a certain fluidity of information.

>Designing a house to express identity is like buying an SUV because it makes you feel like an adventurer and not a soccer mom.

>Stay within yourself. General sports advice good for everything. Know your limits and play your game. Just because you like something doesn't mean you can design it.

>3d preliminary renderings don't tell you as much about a space as you might think.

>A night light is a poor substitute for a night light room. This is a way of making a Chris Alexander sleeping alcove look more normal. For instance, three bedrooms can share one small room (instead of a hallway). The room is the center of the three bedrooms and provides warmth.